REVIEW: Wizard Afternoon Tea at The Cauldron NYC

Looking for another Harry Potter inspired experience to do in New York?
I recently went on a New York Harry Potter trip and this time I added a new immersive experience: Wizard Afternoon Tea at the Cauldron NYC!
The Wizard Afternoon Tea is the perfect experience for witches and wizards of all ages to enjoy some magical brews, sandwiches, and sweets during their visit to New York City. 
Here's everything you need to know before you book Wizard Afternoon Tea at The Cauldron NYC.

What is Wizard Afternoon Tea at The Cauldron NYC ?

The Cauldron is an interactive restaurant with something to offer for people of all ages, and dietary accommodations, while also priding itself as an LGBTQ+ friendly safe space.
Wizard Afternoon Tea  is an interactive tea brewing experience where you can practice spell casting and enjoy some really yummy eats.
In large part, it’s a self-guided experience where you get try out recipes via a downloaded digital menu. You get to invent your own tea concoctions by using mortars, pestles, and vials with provided ingredients. During the experience you get to  borrow a magic wand that interacts with your table set up. Think  like Universal Orlando’s Wizarding World of Harry Potter interactive spell locations.

Is it an Official Harry Potter Themed Afternoon Tea? 

No. The Cauldron NYC is not affiliated with Warner Brothers, Wizarding World or Harry Potter in any way. The whimsical atmosphere, and brewing your own teas makes you feel like you’re a wizard or witch at Hogwart’s!

What’s Included at Wizard Afternoon Tea at The Cauldron NYC?

  • Magic wand and equipment rental to control your tea stand & open your locked chest, which contains your brewing ingredients
  • Brew 2 interactive teas
  • Curated selection of 2 sandwiches per person, 1 scone, & a few small desserts
  • 1 hour and 45 mins experience

Tea Brewing Experience:

The 1st tea focuses on transfiguration. You each choose 3 flavors you think will compliment each other best. I chose Camomile, hibiscus, & lavender.

The 2nd tea is designed to encourage experimentation for finding the perfect concoction. You get a series of 3 teas which start out a pretty dark  blue  color. They then change color before your eyes as you add the final ingredients – and wave your magic wand, of course. Brewing the second tea felt the most like being in Professor Snape’s  potions class.

Wizard Afternoon Tea Food Experience:

Each person starts by selecting 2 sand-which's of their choice. Here was our menu for reference:
Everything is presented on a gorgeous Dragon Egg tea stand that includes finger sandwiches, scones, and multiple desserts to enjoy during your afternoon tea. 
Try more sandwiches by having those at your table order different items. We shared the honey butter avocado, cucumber & cream cheese, smoked salmon, & arugula + hummus.
The scone was warm & flaky. Paired with potted cream it was an 11/10! I also liked the Orange marmalade with my scone. I was actually pleasantly surprised by how yummy the food was, not going to lie. They were very tasty, fresh, and were a generous portion size.
The other small desserts ranged from macarons, cupcakes, tarts and a fancy adult rice krispies treat.
Vegan + Vegetarian options are available! Just note there may be an up charge for these.

Where is Wizard Afternoon Tea at The Cauldron NYC Located?

The Cauldron New York City  is a 2 floor, wizard-themed bar and restaurant with indoor dining and outdoor terrace seating on the cobblestones of historic Stone Street—the oldest paved road in Manhattan!
  • Address: 47 Stone St, New York, NY 10004

How much is Wizard Afternoon Tea at The Cauldron NYC?

  • Adult Afternoon Tea: $59.99
  • The Little Wizard’s Afternoon Tea: $49.99 
    • Ages 11 and under
  • To purchase tickets for Wizard Afternoon Tea at The Cauldron NYC, you’ll need to buy them online and in advance.

Is Wizard Afternoon Tea at The Cauldron NYC Experience Worth It?

Yes!  I would definitely say this experience is worth the cost of the ticket, and I would recommend the Wizard Afternoon tea to those looking for magical and immersive Harry Potter themed experiences in New York City.
It’s the perfect foodie experience to pair with doing Harry Potter: The Exhibition NYC, the Harry Potter New York Store, and seeing Harry Potter and Cursed Child Play. 
It also makes for an excellent “Harry Potter” fix for those who can’t make it back to the WWoHP at Universal Orlando anytime soon.

Overall Review of Wizard Afternoon Tea at The Cauldron NYC 

Adults and kids will enjoy using their wands to pour drinks, and solve simple puzzles to unlock boxes. There’s plenty of wow factor value as you enjoy a wide variety of finger sandwiches, desserts, and scone.
The only thing I would say be prepared for the teas and desserts to be on the sweet side. There is not a lot of savory food  options during his experience.
I really appreciated not feeling rushed during Wizard Afternoon Tea.

Tips For Experiencing Wizard Afternoon Tea at The Cauldron NYC 

  • Dress for the occasion! Wear your favorite Hogwarts house outfit, and bring your robe to wear!
  • If you have a group bigger than 4, be prepared for folks to be split into 2 tables.
  • The Cauldron NYC  is located in Manhattan's Financial District. If doing a Harry Potter weekend trip, it's a good idea to map out the order your doing each experience. This will prevent ping ponging around NYC, and you'll save on Uber fees.
    • I would personally try to plan see Harry Potter and The Cursed Child, Harry Potter New York, and Harry Potter: The Exhibition experiences grouped together since they are all about 15-20 minutes from each other.
    • We ended our New York trip with The Cauldron NYC, & then headed to the LGA airport (28 minute drive before traffic)

FAQ: Wizard Afternoon Tea at The Cauldron NYC

Here’s information and answers to frequently asked questions about the Wizard Afternoon Tea at The Cauldron NYC

Is Wizard Afternoon Tea at The Cauldron NYC family friendly?

I would say yes, absolutely. They even offer a special 11 & under ticket price. Just note there's not really an area for them to get up & move around.

What time is Wizard Afternoon Tea at The Cauldron NYC offered at?

  • Monday - Thursday (last booking 2:30pm)

  • Friday (last booking 12:30pm)

  • Saturday - Sunday (last booking 10:30am)

Can you purchase addition teas or drinks during Wizard Afternoon Tea?

Yes! Additional drinks can be purchased online before your visit for a discounted rate.

Other Magical Experiences at The Cauldron NYC

Aside from Wizard Afternoon Tea, the Cauldron NYC offers a Potion Making class that you can book during your NYC trip.

Potion Making at The Cauldron NYC Ticket includes:

  • Welcome drink that you pour (mixed cocktail or mocktail)
  • 2 molecular cocktails (or mocktails) that you brew
  • 1 Hour and 45 minute interactive experience
  • $49.99 per adult
  •  Interactive Potions List seasonally change
  • Vegan and gluten-free potion drinks are available

Pictured- Potion Making expereince in Edingburgh, Scotland

 
As a Harry Potter fan and lover of all things magical, you’ll have a fabulous time at any of the Cauldon Pub locations!

Disclosure:

I was invited to attend Wizard Afternoon Tea at The Cauldron NYC for the purpose of this review across my social media channels. All opinions are my own.